Food quality has been inconsistent ever since we started to get food from here. And the level of carelessness had reached its new low last night when I ordered a side Caesar salad & found this in my takeout bag.
Sunny Skys
-
May 25, 2024
Great place, wonderful people and delicious pizza. Everything was amazing. Salad was very tasty and fresh. Calzone was stuffed with meat and cheese. Kids order of chicken tenders was huge. This place is a winner!!! Best Coke freestyle machine. Will definitely be back. During the week there is specials and discounts on some items. Thank you Sue.
John Armstrong
-
October 24, 2024
Over the years, my wife and I have tried most of the pizza places in our area. We always come back to Manhattan Pizza very consistent. Aalways high-quality ingredients. The Crust Is always cooked just right. Manhattan always gets the orders done correctly And the pick up times are always accurate. They always have a great selection of toppings available..
Randy L
-
August 29, 2024
First off, we only had take out pizza, so this review is limited to just that experience and not the food in general.
The place had a nice, vibrant atmosphere and the girl behind the counter could not have been nicer or more pleasant. We saw so many great reviews and my family is missing NYC quality pizza, so we thought we had our comfort food close to our new home.
After picking up our plain pie and driving home, about 15 minutes later, we opened the box and saw, what looked to be a decent pizza, but looks were certainly deceiving. The crust had a cardboard like texture and was very dry. I prefer a more acidic pizza sauce and Manhattan Pizza delivered on that, but the flavor was very lacking. The cheese did not seem to be a good quality either, so the 3 primary components of the pizza were a miss. I'd actually rate the pizza at, or slightly below, the common national pizza chain pizzas and I'll have to rotate a few of the other, better local places as our "go-to" until we find one that's great.
At some point in the future, we'll try a menu item or two and adjust accordingly, if needed. It seems many people are happy with the place, but I cannot see exactly why.
Syd
-
November 02, 2024
I used to love coming to Manhattan Pizza for its great food and clean atmosphere, but unfortunately, the service has become a deal-breaker. I recently ordered five items and was told they’d be ready in 20 minutes. When I arrived, only one of the five items was ready. This isn’t the first time I’ve experienced long wait times here; once, I waited 45 minutes just for a wrap and some chips. The food might be good, but the constant delays make it not worth it.
Update: I had to wait nearly an hour for my order, which was frustrating. My sister enjoyed her pizza and fries, but my mom’s chicken Parmesan sandwich was disappointing – the chicken was overcooked, and she ended up only eating the bread. I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap, but unfortunately, the wrap itself was hard. Not worth the wait for me.
Our Address
305 Matthews Dr, Holly Springs, NC 27540, USA
Claim Listing: Manhattan Pizza
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Food quality has been inconsistent ever since we started to get food from here. And the level of carelessness had reached its new low last night when I ordered a side Caesar salad & found this in my takeout bag.
Great place, wonderful people and delicious pizza. Everything was amazing. Salad was very tasty and fresh. Calzone was stuffed with meat and cheese. Kids order of chicken tenders was huge. This place is a winner!!! Best Coke freestyle machine. Will definitely be back. During the week there is specials and discounts on some items. Thank you Sue.
Over the years, my wife and I have tried most of the pizza places in our area. We always come back to Manhattan Pizza very consistent. Aalways high-quality ingredients. The Crust Is always cooked just right. Manhattan always gets the orders done correctly And the pick up times are always accurate. They always have a great selection of toppings available..
First off, we only had take out pizza, so this review is limited to just that experience and not the food in general. The place had a nice, vibrant atmosphere and the girl behind the counter could not have been nicer or more pleasant. We saw so many great reviews and my family is missing NYC quality pizza, so we thought we had our comfort food close to our new home. After picking up our plain pie and driving home, about 15 minutes later, we opened the box and saw, what looked to be a decent pizza, but looks were certainly deceiving. The crust had a cardboard like texture and was very dry. I prefer a more acidic pizza sauce and Manhattan Pizza delivered on that, but the flavor was very lacking. The cheese did not seem to be a good quality either, so the 3 primary components of the pizza were a miss. I'd actually rate the pizza at, or slightly below, the common national pizza chain pizzas and I'll have to rotate a few of the other, better local places as our "go-to" until we find one that's great. At some point in the future, we'll try a menu item or two and adjust accordingly, if needed. It seems many people are happy with the place, but I cannot see exactly why.
I used to love coming to Manhattan Pizza for its great food and clean atmosphere, but unfortunately, the service has become a deal-breaker. I recently ordered five items and was told they’d be ready in 20 minutes. When I arrived, only one of the five items was ready. This isn’t the first time I’ve experienced long wait times here; once, I waited 45 minutes just for a wrap and some chips. The food might be good, but the constant delays make it not worth it. Update: I had to wait nearly an hour for my order, which was frustrating. My sister enjoyed her pizza and fries, but my mom’s chicken Parmesan sandwich was disappointing – the chicken was overcooked, and she ended up only eating the bread. I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap, but unfortunately, the wrap itself was hard. Not worth the wait for me.